Relocation Savings Calculator
Your Potential Savings
Current State:
Target State:
Current Housing Cost: $
New Housing Cost: $
Savings Percentage: %
Quick Takeaways
- The five states that feel most financially painful in 2024 are California, New York, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Maryland.
- High cost‑of‑living indexes, steep tax burdens, and low housing affordability are the main culprits.
- Median household income in these states still lags behind the cost pressures, widening the affordability gap.
- Moving to a lower‑cost state can cut everyday expenses by 30‑40% on average.
- If relocation isn’t possible, targeted budgeting, remote‑work gigs, and housing subsidies can ease the squeeze.
When you hear the question “what is the hardest state to live in financially?” you’re really asking which state forces its residents to spend the most of every paycheck on basic needs. That answer changes over time, but the latest data from 2024 gives a clear picture.
Hardest state financially is a shorthand for "the U.S. state where the combination of living costs, taxes, and income levels creates the greatest financial strain for an average household." It’s not just about pricey rent; it’s the whole economic ecosystem - housing, taxes, wages, and even local inflation. Below we break down the method, the top contenders, why they rank where they do, and what you can do if you’re stuck in one of these high‑stress markets.
How We Ranked States
Our ranking blends three core data points, each marked up as a distinct entity for easy reference.
Cost of Living Index (COLI) comes from the Council for Community and Economic Research (C2ER) 2024 report. The index sets 100 as the national average; anything above signals higher-than‑average expenses.
Median Household Income is pulled from the U.S. Census Bureau 2023 American Community Survey, reflecting the middle income point for families in each state.
Housing Affordability Ratio measures the median home price divided by median household income. Ratios above 4.0 indicate that a typical family would need more than four years of income to buy a home.
We also layered two secondary metrics - State Tax Burden Score (a composite of income, sales, and property taxes) and Unemployment Rate from the BLS 2024 monthly release - to capture hidden costs.
Each metric was normalized to a 0‑100 scale and weighted (COLI 40%, Income 25%, Housing 20%, Tax Burden 10%, Unemployment 5%). The higher the final score, the harder it is to make ends meet.
Top 5 Hardest States in 2024
| State | Cost of Living Index | Median Household Income (USD) | Housing Affordability Ratio | State Tax Burden Score | Unemployment Rate (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| California | 151.2 | 84,300 | 5.2 | 88 | 4.1 |
| New York | 147.5 | 78,900 | 5.0 | 92 | 4.0 |
| Hawaii | 185.7 | 81,200 | 6.8 | 79 | 3.2 |
| Massachusetts | 148.9 | 85,600 | 4.7 | 85 | 3.8 |
| Maryland | 141.3 | 88,500 | 4.5 | 84 | 3.9 |
These states share a common DNA: sky‑high housing markets, aggressive tax structures, and wages that haven’t kept pace with rising expenses.
Why These States Feel So Expensive
Let’s unpack the five levers that push the numbers up.
1. Cost of Living Index (COLI)
California’s COLI of 151 means everyday goods - groceries, gas, childcare - cost about 51% more than the U.S. average. New York and Massachusetts hover around the 48‑49% mark. Hawaii tops the chart at 186, driven largely by its isolation and import‑heavy economy.
2. Housing Affordability
When the median home price outstrips median income by more than four times, renters feel the pinch too. In California, the median home price sits near $1.3million, while the median income is just $84k, yielding a ratio of 5.2. Hawaii’s ratio spikes to 6.8, reflecting sky‑high condo prices on limited land.
3. State Tax Burden
New York’s tax score of 92 is a blend of a top‑bracket income tax (up to 10.9%), high sales tax, and hefty property taxes. Massachusetts and California also rank in the high‑80s, meaning a larger slice of each paycheck vanishes to government coffers.
4. Stagnant Income Growth
Even though California’s median income tops $84k, it lags behind the state’s cost pressures. In contrast, Texas (not in our top‑5) shows a lower COLI (98) but a median income of $71k, allowing residents to stretch dollars further.
5. Unemployment Pressure
While unemployment rates above 4% aren’t alarming, they compound financial strain when jobs are scarce in high‑cost metros. California’s 4.1% and New York’s 4.0% reflect competitive markets where even employed workers may under‑earn.
What to Do If You’re Stuck in One of These States
Leaving isn’t always feasible, so here are five concrete actions that can blunt the blow.
- Cut Housing Costs: Consider relocating from a city core to an outer suburb or a nearby smaller town. In California, moving from San Francisco to Sacramento can shave $1,200 off monthly rent.
- Boost Income with Remote Work: Many tech, design, and consulting roles pay national rates while letting you stay in a high‑cost state. Aim for a remote salary at least 20% above your local market.
- Leverage Tax Credits: Both California and New York offer earned‑income tax credits for low‑to‑moderate earners. Filing early and using a tax‑prep service can reclaim several hundred dollars.
- Utilize Housing Assistance Programs: State‑run affordable‑housing lotteries and Section8 vouchers still exist; eligibility often hinges on income-to‑rent ratios, which many high‑cost residents meet.
- Adopt Frugal Lifestyle Hacks: Bulk grocery shopping, public‑transport passes, and DIY home maintenance can cut everyday spend by 10‑15%.
Cheaper Alternatives - States That Offer Relief
If relocation is on the table, these five states rank as the most affordable in 2024. They combine low COLI scores (80‑90), reasonable housing ratios (under 4.0), and modest tax burdens.
- Missouri - COLI 86, median income $61k, housing ratio 3.6.
- Indiana - COLI 88, median income $63k, housing ratio 3.5.
- Kentucky - COLI 84, median income $58k, housing ratio 3.4.
- Oklahoma - COLI 85, median income $55k, housing ratio 3.3.
- Texas - COLI 98, median income $71k, housing ratio 3.9, but with no state income tax.
Each of these states offers a balanced mix of job opportunities and lower day‑to‑day costs, making them attractive for anyone looking to stretch a paycheck.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which factor contributes most to a state’s financial hardness?
Housing affordability is usually the biggest driver. Even if wages are high, exorbitant rent or home prices can eat up 30‑50% of income, leaving little for other needs.
Can I qualify for federal or state assistance in high‑cost states?
Yes. Programs like the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), and state‑specific housing vouchers target households where income‑to‑cost ratios exceed 30%.
Does a high cost of living mean higher salaries?
Not always. While tech hubs in California pay premium wages, many service‑sector jobs still earn near‑national averages, creating a gap between income and expenses.
Are there any states where taxes offset the high cost of living?
Some high‑tax states, like New York, offer robust public services (transit, education) that can reduce personal expenses. Still, the net effect usually leaves residents paying more overall.
How often do these rankings change?
Rankings can shift yearly as housing markets swing, wages adjust, or tax policies evolve. Keeping an eye on the annual C2ER COLI report and Census income updates is the best way to stay current.
Understanding why a state feels financially brutal can help you make smarter decisions-whether that means tightening your budget, negotiating a better remote salary, or packing your bags for a more affordable corner of the country.